A Code Left Unfinished in Manila
![clean data visualization, flat 2D chart, muted academic palette, no 3D effects, evidence-based presentation, professional infographic, minimal decoration, clear axis labels, scholarly aesthetic, A minimalist two-dimensional bar chart on a white grid background, the bar 80% filled in muted blue, the remaining 20% empty with faint dashed outline, labeled "SCS CoC Negotiations – 2024" at the bottom; thin black axes with precise tick marks, no decorations or shadows; flat overhead lighting casting no shadows, sterile and clinical atmosphere emphasizing absence and precision [fal-ai/z-image/turbo] clean data visualization, flat 2D chart, muted academic palette, no 3D effects, evidence-based presentation, professional infographic, minimal decoration, clear axis labels, scholarly aesthetic, A minimalist two-dimensional bar chart on a white grid background, the bar 80% filled in muted blue, the remaining 20% empty with faint dashed outline, labeled "SCS CoC Negotiations – 2024" at the bottom; thin black axes with precise tick marks, no decorations or shadows; flat overhead lighting casting no shadows, sterile and clinical atmosphere emphasizing absence and precision [fal-ai/z-image/turbo]](https://cdn.digitalrain.dev/thelongview/viral-images/e22c5581-8099-42e2-bea4-7a49bea4e504_viral_4_square.jpg)
If the legal status and geographic scope of the South China Sea code remain unresolved, then Singapore’s chairmanship inherits a negotiation framework requiring new concessions from all parties.
Negotiations on the code have run for more than two decades, and the Philippines, as chair, had committed to conclude it this year. Foreign minister Ma. Theresa Lazaro told a press conference at the summit of the 11-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations in Manila that several key issues remain open, including whether the code would be legally binding.
Legal status is the binding constraint. Southeast Asian neighbours of China want the code grounded in international law, a principle they say Beijing has disregarded while asserting sovereignty over nearly all of the South China Sea. Beijing maintains that its actions there have been lawful and professional, and it rejects the 2016 arbitration ruling that its sweeping claims have no basis under international law.
Exposure follows from geography. China's claims overlap the exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Vietnam, which is why a functional code is meant to prevent escalation and manage incidents at sea. Manila and Beijing have meanwhile been locked in a series of confrontations, which the Philippines describes as dangerous manoeuvres, water-cannoning and disruption of resupply missions, and which China answers with its charge that the Philippines intrudes into what it regards as Chinese territory.
The divisions are not only between ASEAN and China. Collin Koh of Singapore's S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies said intramural divergences, including over the geographical scope of the code, have also slowed the talks. He said the remaining differences would be difficult to resolve and would require major concessions from the various parties.
Singapore inherits the chairmanship next year and with it the task of securing agreement on questions of legal status and geographic scope that the Philippines could not close in Manila.
† Analysis: the writer's conclusion from the reported facts, not a fact stated in the source.
- The article draws the inference that the remaining differences in the negotiations will be difficult to resolve and will require major concessions based on the expert commentary provided by Collin Koh in the source.
Published November 15, 2026